Critiquing Songs - Musicians Post Here

Xoosh · Post by **Xoosh** » Tue Jan 07, 2003 11:29 pm

I dont know how this will work or if it'll even be effective. I will be moderating it to keep the subject intact... ie: no pointless conversation here (like random posting for no reason... it'll be a sticky(edit jkanter: not anymore...top it if you guys need to), so there will be no need to "top" the thread).

What i think will work best is if we post our songs and when you do a critique of them you simply write something like:

XoOsh: I think your song "Missing You" is...

That way we can avoid confusion. I'll probably delete the thread after 50-60 posts and start it over for a fresh start... or unsticky it and make a new thread with the same idea for another 50-60 posts.

Let the songs roll in.

As for my song, no one seemed to comment on:

http://www.eastofbeautiful.com/files/mi ... ixdown.mp3 - Missing You

Regards,
X

DmbFanJason · Post by **DmbFanJason** » Wed Jan 08, 2003 3:22 am

hey man..what the hell happened here?

i thought it was supposed to be a sticky???????

Xoosh · Post by **Xoosh** » Wed Jan 08, 2003 4:00 am

jkanter and i agreed we'll do this when the board gets a face lift. no worries

it'll come back bigger and better.

/x

MattyTrane · Post by **MattyTrane** » Wed Jan 08, 2003 8:56 pm

so we are doing the mp3 thread thing?

afro1669 · Post by **afro1669** » Sun Jan 12, 2003 8:49 pm

Xoosh wrote:I dont know how this will work or if it'll even be effective. I will be moderating it to keep the subject intact... ie: no pointless conversation here (like random posting for no reason... it'll be a sticky(edit jkanter: not anymore...top it if you guys need to), so there will be no need to "top" the thread).

What i think will work best is if we post our songs and when you do a critique of them you simply write something like:

XoOsh: I think your song "Missing You" is...

That way we can avoid confusion. I'll probably delete the thread after 50-60 posts and start it over for a fresh start... or unsticky it and make a new thread with the same idea for another 50-60 posts.

Let the songs roll in.

As for my song, no one seemed to comment on:

http://www.eastofbeautiful.com/files/mi ... ixdown.mp3 - Missing You

Regards,
X

that's really good, it sounds really cool. i'm no great musician or anything but i really like that.
peace, brendan

Davefan0886 · Post by **Davefan0886** » Sun Jan 12, 2003 9:21 pm

I really like the song Xoosh, good job

DMBTabs.com

Critiquing Songs - Musicians Post Here

Critiquing Songs - Musicians Post Here

Re: Critiquing Songs - Musicians Post Here