Mayer.....
- MahlerGrooves
- DMBTabs.com Regular
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2005 11:29 pm
- Location: New York, NY & Stuttgart, Germany
- Contact:
I am so amazed at people trying to pin certain music as "real." Isn't all music real? No matter how much a specific person likes or dislikes a specific artist, that does not make that artist's efforts any less "real."
I am someone who will listen to a Bach cantata, a Beethoven symphony, Wagner opera and DMB CD all back to back. No one is any more "real" than any other.
All that matters is that an artist do what they want. Beethoven was vilified during his time for writing "repugnant" music, and now we count him as a genius. Leonard Bernstein was the music director of the NY Philharmonic AND wrote West Side Story.
In fact, John Mayer, in my opinion, is very similar to Bernstein. He is such a skilled guitarist (he DID go to Berkley) schooled in all the complexities of jazz and blues, yet he is still capable of writing some of the most radio-friendly tunes in recent memory.
As long as there has been music, certain people have liked or disliked specific composers/artists. That does not mean that any one person is more or less "real." It is all preference. I just cannot stomach people trying to make a blanket statement about an artist's skill because they do not like their product.
I absolutely detest the music of Jessica Simpson, but I respect her for being successful and having talent in the area of music she enjoys. Is she less musically knowledgable and technically skilled than Beethoven? Probably. Does that make her music any less real? Not at all.
I am someone who will listen to a Bach cantata, a Beethoven symphony, Wagner opera and DMB CD all back to back. No one is any more "real" than any other.
All that matters is that an artist do what they want. Beethoven was vilified during his time for writing "repugnant" music, and now we count him as a genius. Leonard Bernstein was the music director of the NY Philharmonic AND wrote West Side Story.
In fact, John Mayer, in my opinion, is very similar to Bernstein. He is such a skilled guitarist (he DID go to Berkley) schooled in all the complexities of jazz and blues, yet he is still capable of writing some of the most radio-friendly tunes in recent memory.
As long as there has been music, certain people have liked or disliked specific composers/artists. That does not mean that any one person is more or less "real." It is all preference. I just cannot stomach people trying to make a blanket statement about an artist's skill because they do not like their product.
I absolutely detest the music of Jessica Simpson, but I respect her for being successful and having talent in the area of music she enjoys. Is she less musically knowledgable and technically skilled than Beethoven? Probably. Does that make her music any less real? Not at all.
-Chris Rosina
Proud owner of:
-Taylor 410-LTD!!!!!
-German made Double-Bass (year 1875)
"Über den Wolken, muß die Freiheit wohl grenzenlos sein."
Proud owner of:
-Taylor 410-LTD!!!!!
-German made Double-Bass (year 1875)
"Über den Wolken, muß die Freiheit wohl grenzenlos sein."
- MahlerGrooves
- DMBTabs.com Regular
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2005 11:29 pm
- Location: New York, NY & Stuttgart, Germany
- Contact:
- chosta
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 34473
- Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2003 8:33 pm
- Political views: red sox
- Random movie quote to make you seem hip and "with it": i know a good sand guy, we can get it at a price
- Location: the deep blue
- Contact:
mmm.....profit
-Matt
checkii wrote:It's cool to hate on Chosta, I get it. But the prejudice that people take into his posts makes people so stupid it's hilarious to read. I take every gif I watch (which is A LOT) with a humongous grain of salt. But I don't let that grain of salt get into my eye and blind me to whatever truth can be found in what I'm watching. He is not any worse than any other poster here, and the people who claim he is just don't know what they're talking about. The demonization has gotten ridiculously out of hand.
-
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 1893
- Joined: Sun Jun 13, 2004 12:29 pm
- Location: South Florida
- Contact:
Beautiful! I agree 100%MahlerGrooves wrote:I am so amazed at people trying to pin certain music as "real." Isn't all music real? No matter how much a specific person likes or dislikes a specific artist, that does not make that artist's efforts any less "real."
I am someone who will listen to a Bach cantata, a Beethoven symphony, Wagner opera and DMB CD all back to back. No one is any more "real" than any other.
All that matters is that an artist do what they want. Beethoven was vilified during his time for writing "repugnant" music, and now we count him as a genius. Leonard Bernstein was the music director of the NY Philharmonic AND wrote West Side Story.
In fact, John Mayer, in my opinion, is very similar to Bernstein. He is such a skilled guitarist (he DID go to Berkley) schooled in all the complexities of jazz and blues, yet he is still capable of writing some of the most radio-friendly tunes in recent memory.
As long as there has been music, certain people have liked or disliked specific composers/artists. That does not mean that any one person is more or less "real." It is all preference. I just cannot stomach people trying to make a blanket statement about an artist's skill because they do not like their product.
I absolutely detest the music of Jessica Simpson, but I respect her for being successful and having talent in the area of music she enjoys. Is she less musically knowledgable and technically skilled than Beethoven? Probably. Does that make her music any less real? Not at all.
" I give up on this six string shit. "
-DM
-DM
Are ya'll mad becasue a newbie was right? Even Brock was completely wrong. Refer to where he says re-read his posts. You guys make me sick with your bandwagon shit sometimes. If Brock or somebody with a high post count thinks a certain idea, ya'll just jump on like mindless lemmings.
*shakes head in disgust*
*shakes head in disgust*
- Beauford33
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 19055
- Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2003 11:08 pm
- Random movie quote to make you seem hip and "with it": A little bit of column A and a little bit of column B...
- Location: Denver
You have invented the "post card". Where most would use the "race card" you use the "post card"...genius.jellyfish wrote:Are ya'll mad becasue a newbie was right? Even Brock was completely wrong. Refer to where he says re-read his posts. You guys make me sick with your bandwagon shit sometimes. If Brock or somebody with a high post count thinks a certain idea, ya'll just jump on like mindless lemmings.
*shakes head in disgust*
-BK
What?Beauford33 wrote:You have invented the "post card". Where most would use the "race card" you use the "post card"...genius.jellyfish wrote:Are ya'll mad becasue a newbie was right? Even Brock was completely wrong. Refer to where he says re-read his posts. You guys make me sick with your bandwagon shit sometimes. If Brock or somebody with a high post count thinks a certain idea, ya'll just jump on like mindless lemmings.
*shakes head in disgust*

I call em' like I see em'
- Beauford33
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 19055
- Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2003 11:08 pm
- Random movie quote to make you seem hip and "with it": A little bit of column A and a little bit of column B...
- Location: Denver
Im just saying you have found a new way to make yourself...as well as all newbs the victum. Be means of this alleged post-card. I like it.jellyfish wrote:What?Beauford33 wrote:You have invented the "post card". Where most would use the "race card" you use the "post card"...genius.jellyfish wrote:Are ya'll mad becasue a newbie was right? Even Brock was completely wrong. Refer to where he says re-read his posts. You guys make me sick with your bandwagon shit sometimes. If Brock or somebody with a high post count thinks a certain idea, ya'll just jump on like mindless lemmings.
*shakes head in disgust*![]()
I call em' like I see em'
-BK
- Beauford33
- DMBTabs.com Authority
- Posts: 19055
- Joined: Sun Jun 29, 2003 11:08 pm
- Random movie quote to make you seem hip and "with it": A little bit of column A and a little bit of column B...
- Location: Denver
Return to “General Guitar Discussion”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 158 guests